Pragmatic defence of the register system: strengthening Clarkes consequentialist case for managing conscientious objection
Introduction The debate over conscientious objection (CO) in healthcare remains deeply polarised, often framed as a clash between professional obligations and individual moral integrity. In their consequentialist defence of permitting CO, Steve Clarke proposes a region-based register of non-objecting professionals as a mechanism to minimise reliance on referrals—what they aptly term a ‘fight without fighting’ approach. This commentary supports Clarke’s core argument but s
Record details
Published: 22 July 2026
Source: Journal of Medical Ethics (BMJ)
Category: Research
Topics: Healthcare · Military & security
Retrieved: 23 July 2026
Related evidence
These records share source-supplied organisations, an exact publisher byline, automatic topics or regions. The reason is shown on every link; related does not mean supporting, agreeing with or verifying this record.
Mapping Machine Learning–Driven Cybersecurity Solutions in Health Care: Scoping Literature Review
JMIR (Journal of Medical Internet Research) · 27 July 2026
Threat Vectors and the State of the Art in Defense Methods for Security in Neurotechnology
arXiv cs.CR (AI security) · 11 July 2026
Toward Resilient Human-AI Collaboration: A Lifecycle Taxonomy of Sociotechnical Risks and Cascading Failures
arXiv cs.HC · 6 August 2026
TRACE: A Multi-Layer Benchmark for Human AI Controller Coordination Under Drift and Failure
arXiv · 7 August 2026
SEVA: Self-Evolving Verification Agent with Process Reward for Fact Attribution
arXiv · 29 June 2026
Explainable AI-Driven Cyber Risk Analytics and Model Reliability Assessment for Intelligent Governance of U.S. Critical Infrastructure: An XGBoost and SHAP-Based Intrusion Detection Framework
arXiv · 4 June 2026
How to cite this record
ethics.ai (22 July 2026), “Pragmatic defence of the register system: strengthening Clarkes consequentialist case for managing conscientious objection,” evidence record 12746, https://ethics.ai/record/12746 (originally published by Journal of Medical Ethics (BMJ)).
Use and limitations
This page is a stable index and citation surface for a source record. ethics.ai did not author the underlying report and has not independently verified every claim. Automatic topics may be imperfect. For consequential use, quote and cite the original publisher.